Easy Buckeye Recipe

Creamy peanut butter buckeye balls dipped in chocolate. This easy no-bake candy is a peanut butter lover’s dream come true!

Creamy Peanut Butter Buckeyes

I was first introduced to the buckeyes when I moved to Ohio 6 years ago. They are sold everywhere there! My favorite ice cream shop (Mr. Freeze) had the BEST buckeye sundae. My life was changed for the better.

Over the years I’ve made a few buckeye desserts like my buckeye brownies and chocolate cupcakes with peanut butter frosting, but I just realized I never posted the classic recipe. It’s basically peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate. I mean, how could you go wrong?!

These are also great treats to make for Christmas. We love adding them to our goodie plates, decorated Christmas cookies, and other candy recipes.

5 Simple Ingredients

The best part about these buckeyes (other than their delicious taste) is that you only need 5 ingredients to make them! Combine all the ingredients then dip in chocolate for the perfect combination. These are simple treats that are loved by all!

Find the full printable recipe with specific measurements below.

1. Peanut butter: Make sure to use creamy peanut butter in this recipe. You won’t get the same result with a natural, drippy type.
2. Butter: Use unsalted butter for the best taste. Also, make sure it’s been softened before getting started.
3. Vanilla: A boost of vanilla adds the perfect touch to these buckeyes. Pure vanilla extract will give you the best flavor.
4. Powdered sugar: This helps sweeten them up while adding a thick texture.
5. Chocolate: Semi-sweet chocolate is my favorite, however dark chocolate would tastes delicious too. I prefer to use chocolate melting wafers because of their extra smooth consistency when melted, but you can also use chocolate chips if that’s what you have on hand.

How to Make Buckeyes

Make a peanut butter mixture that is soft and creamy. Roll into balls and place on parchment paper. When ready, dip it in the chocolate. It is that simple to make these buckeyes!

• Combine peanut butter mixture. Mix together peanut butter, butter, and vanilla with an electric mixer. Gradually add in 1 cup powdered sugar and mix until well combined. Add the last 1/2-3/4 cup powdered sugar and mix with your hands until all the sugar is gone. The consistency should be thick. If it’s too sticky, add more powdered sugar.
• Form into balls. Shape dough into 1-inch balls and roll until smooth. Place on a parchment-lined baking sheet and freeze for 15 minutes.
• Melt the chocolate. Melt the chocolate in the microwave for 60 seconds or in a double boiler. Stir until smooth.
• Dip in chocolate. Remove from the freezer and stick a toothpick in the center (don’t go too far down or it will be hard to get out). Dip the buckeye ball 3/4 of the way into the melted chocolate. Allow the chocolate to drizzle off and then place it back on the parchment paper. Let set for a minute and then gently remove the toothpick. Repeat.

Tips for Success

Here are a few tips to help you make the best buckeyes ever! Use these ideas to make it go smoothly. They are perfect to serve for parties or as a snack!

• I use a small cookie scoop to form my buckeyes evenly. Then roll them in my hands to create a super smooth texture.
• I prefer using longer toothpicks when dipping my buckeyes into chocolate. They’re easier to hold and less messy.
• If you don’t want to see the toothpick hole, just press down gently once they are set and they will close. I like to keep them there because that’s how the ones that are sold in Ohio look.

Storing + Freezing

These buckeye balls are best stored in the refrigerator so that they keep their shape and texture. Simply place them in an airtight container or bag and store them in the fridge for up to 1 week.

If you’d like to freeze the buckeyes, I’d recommend flash-freezing them first so that they don’t stick together. Place them on a baking sheet and freeze for about 30 minutes, or until hard. Then place in a freezer container and store for up to 2 months.

More Easy Candy Recipe

HUNGRY FOR MORE? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all the newest recipes!